Late night talk shows, though regimented and predictable in the general sense, don’t have this issue. They may be rehearsed to an extent, but it’s easy to tell that little thought or planning goes into each segment. With each show required to fill an hour a day, five nights a week, there’s simply not enough time to make it flawless. They’re all grasping at straws all the time.
That’s why you’ll see hosts screw up punch lines, sketch props fall over, guests go on strange story tangents, and numerous other “mistakes.” The beauty is that none of it matters – the in-house audience got in for free and the viewers at home are likely half-asleep and never had high expectations anyway.
What’s amusing is that these shows still rely on the same show format Carson was doing 30 years ago. The hosts still wear suits and the nightly schedule has changed very little – monologue, sketch, two guests and a musical act or comedian. Night after night, week after week, year after year. It’s become so familiar to viewers that something as simple as having a musical act play before the guests come out would be confusing.
What has changed and will continue to change is the style of humor. Since the tone of each show so heavily relies on the host, it is only natural that Dave Letterman’s show is nothing like Jay Leno’s, whose is nothing like Jimmy Fallon’s, whose is nothing like Craig Ferguson’s and so on and so forth.
Personally, I’m not a fan of a few of the late night hosts, but the perk of all these shows is that they have the capacity to be interesting regardless. Take George Lopez for example – I’m ambivalent at best about his comedic style, but when Prince crawls out of his purple bunker to appear as a guest, I’ll still watch him.
Another perk is that the celebrity guests are forced to rely on their real-life personalities and charm to shill whatever they are promoting. Viewers get to see when a star is devoid of both (e.g. Harrison Ford, Robert De Niro). The best guests are often the C-level celebrities and comedians who have been kicking around Hollywood for years trying to retain some level of success, but realized a long time ago they were never going to be huge stars (e.g. Norm McDonald, Chris Elliott).
Ratings for late night shows aren’t what they once were and probably never will be, but the optimist in me believes this type of after-hours chat show will be able to survive for years to come. There will never be a day when the world runs out of celebrity guests and opening monologues will survive as long as politicians continue to have affairs and say stupid things. I’m not too worried.
I come from a generation whose preferred style of comedy is often centered on awkwardness (The Office), shock (Daniel Tosh, Sarah Silverman), endless pop-culture references (Family Guy) and genre parodies (Community). The concept of a comedian who comes out in a suit and cracks jokes about the president and the day’s headlines while standing under a “Laugh” sign borders on archaic.
That’s what’s I like about late night shows. In this day and age, a little old-fashioned show business, a few cheap jokes and genuine enthusiasm actually comes off as refreshing. There are worse ways to drift to sleep.